Carrie Everingham


M: 614-746-5690

Contact Me My Website

Make Preferred Realtor
Carrie Everingham - Cutler Real Estate Agent


Buyer's Agent, Condominiums, Listing Agent, New Construction, Relocation, Residential


Dog Lover, Family, Hiking / Camping, Music, Parenting, Traveling


Cutler Real Estate asked Carrie a few questions so you can get to know her better, and here are Carrie's replies.

1. What is your professional/educational background?

Studied marketing at The Ohio State University and then got my real estate license in 2003.

2. Why did you choose a career in real estate?

During college I worked as a server and a bartender and really enjoyed meeting and talking to all kinds of people. Real estate lets me continue to do that while helping them achieve home ownership. Real Estate is one of the biggest investments a person can make and I love being a part of it. Plus I really like touring all of the different homes, even after all of these years I still enjoy it!

3. What area do you live in currently and what do you like about where you live?

I live in Muirfield Village which is a great community in Dublin. It is very family friendly and there are all types of homes there. There are pools, parks, and even fishing ponds that all residents can use. Plus it's just a short drive from my office in Dublin!

4. How do you spend your free time?

Most of my free time is spent with my family. I have a husband named Todd, son Max, and daughter Lauren. They keep me pretty busy! When I'm not with them I enjoy hanging out with my friends and I have a real passion for music. I love to go to concerts!

5. If you could only keep 5 possessions what would they be?

  1. My phone - I can't live without it!
  2. My grandmother's wedding ring
  3. My wedding ring
  4. Box of old family pictures
  5. Photograph of an old VW bus hanging in my house 

6. In one word, how do you think your friends/family would describe you?


7678 Gateway Boulevard
Powell, OH 43065

3 beds 4 bath 2,635 sqft

$514,000 Price Reduced $10,900
7622 Gateway Boulevard
Powell, OH 43065

3 beds 4 bath 2,581 sqft


Dublin, OH

Located just 17 miles from downtown Columbus, Dublin is a lively suburb of the city with lots of natural space, golf courses, business headquarters, and more. This popular city is continually developing and expanding, and is an increasingly popular place to call home. Real Estate Dublin is primarily an affluent city filled with a variety of estate properties, many of which are situated in a pristine country club setting. Homes in Dublin range from modest single-story homes to grandiose properties on expansive lots. Dublin homes...

Learn More
Dublin - Photo 1
Be the first to add
a testimonial below
Add Testimonial
5/5 Based on 29 Ratings
View More Testimonials on Agent Site
Jun 3, 2020

Carrie is absolutely amazing to work with. We have purchased and sold multiple properties with her and she continues to provide us with excellent service. Anytime an issue has come up, Carrie is on top of it and has it solved quickly. She had our most recent property in-contract before it even hit the market. Highly recommend Carrie!

— zuser2016071609...
Apr 25, 2020

Carrie is wonderful! Being young first time home buyers, we were really intimidated and nervous about everything, we had no idea what we were doing. But Carrie was so kind and patient with us that she made it fun! She explained things easily to us when we didn't understand, and was always available to talk or text. Carrie knew so much about the Columbus area and was honest with her opinions on the homes/areas we looked at, which is exactly what we needed. I highly recommend Carrie, especially for first time home buyers!

— ckersch
Dec 21, 2019

Another fantastic experience with Carrie. Buying or selling, she is a professional! We sold the house at asking price, with multiple offers, and during a non-peak buying cycle. The sale price was higher than we expected and is a direct result of Carrie's punch list recommendations, staging services, and marketing plan.

— jcfring6
Oct 6, 2019

Carrie is fabulous. She is thorough, detail orientated, & fun to work with! She always returns calls in a timely manner. Carrie worked very hard to make things as easy as possible through a complex process. Loved working with her!!!!

— cookiekane
Sep 9, 2019

Carrie was absolutely amazing! So attentive and patient with great experience and knowledge. Her communication and connections made this the best experience we could have had.

— user63641341
Jun 26, 2019

Mrs Everingham is an amazing realtor, she made my home buying process easy and less stress. She has great knowledge of the Columbus housing market, the finance process, A+ communication skills and great negotiation skill set. She was able to tell me the pros/cons of different homes, the locations and any additional updates the homes had in them. We view several homes, she had the history of the home and viewing was simply, easy and very informative. I would recommend Mrs. Everingham as a realtor but more as a partner is any home buying process.

— Jerome A. Joseph
Jun 25, 2019

Carrie is the absolute BEST! She really listened to what I wanted and went out of her way to find homes I would like. She was always willing to go and tour a home at a moments notice-which was vital in this market! She made touring the houses fun, and had great insights on what to look out for, which really helped me as a first time homebuyer. When it came time to purchase-she was very skilled and creative in helping me craft an offer than would get accepted. If you’re looking for a realtor Carrie is your girl!

— stacey wilhelm nc
Jun 3, 2019

Carrie made the entire experience easy and much less stressful than anticipated. She was very honest and professional. She set realistic expectations but also followed through with everything she promised on her end.

— user0547552
May 28, 2019

Carrie handled EVERYTHING! I have sold homes before and this was the most efficient and easiest for me by far. She was outstanding , always coming up with great ideas, saving costs, marketing and dealing with everyone involved. A-PLUS Service.

— coconnell2016
Apr 2, 2019

Carrie stepped up to the plate fearlessly and helped us out in a sticky situation that resulted after we submitted an offer. Throughout the year-long search to find a home to move back to after living in another state for ten years, Carrie was outstanding. She was extremely prompt in answering our many questions, she is thoroughly knowledgeable, and made us feel confident with her "can do" spirit. She is a delightful gal and we are sure glad our daughter recommended her to us. I'm paying it forward. I highly recommend Carrie Everingham as your real estate agent.

— suzdonaldson3
View More Testimonials on Agent Site